Do you think the Blue Fairy Always remembered who she was?

If she did always remember then maybe she thinks she can leave w/o any adverse consequences. And if she got everyone else to leave they would forget anything she might have done to them (like grumpy and nova)

hmm...considering she was heading for the towns border i am wondering if she did indeed always remember...seems like something she would NOT do...although I guess if she doesn't have any magic and they are all terrified of Regina that it might make sense...

Ranna156 wrote:well i just saw a spoiler that could explain a lot and still leave the BF not ALWAYS remembering and yet still make sense for a LOT of things.

I am leaving my vote though with her still ALWAYS remembering...would make things interesting if she DID!!!

I think i need to clarify this now...not so sure it was a spoiler in ANY way...i think the ENTIRE comment might just have been someones theory...until i get confirmation by rewatching Skin Deep (or one of you tells me they watched it with the commentary and heard it) I am going on the thought it was ENTIRELY a theory...HOWEVER it DOES make for an interesting twist!

Im going with she always remembered.

I just remembered we saw August talking to BF in storybrooke, he not being affected by the curse totally knew who she really was, i dont think he was just talking about him and Geppetto...

And I'm another who agrees with rra615. Unless they come up with another way for Gold to have gotten Henry other than dumb luck or destiny, I'm going with he knew the entire time. On the BF, she did say she was making preparations before the curse, and August did have a conversation with her in SB, so I wouldn't rule out old Blue.

well i just saw a spoiler that could explain a lot and still leave the BF not ALWAYS remembering and yet still make sense for a LOT of things.

I am leaving my vote though with her still ALWAYS remembering...would make things interesting if she DID!!!

So I'm with rra on Gold, I know the writer's said he didn't remember until Emma told him her name, but it's hard to believe that.

I do think the BF knew the whole time. I think she knew who August was, and i think she was the one who sent the message to the mystery man.

I don't know for sure that she is evil but morraine did say Ruel Ghorm was the oldest and darkest magic, so I'm going with she's the most powerful (when she has fairy dust at least) and that she like Rump is on her own team.

Standing in the way of true love (Dreamy and Nova) does NOT sit right with me, along with the other mis-information she has given people (e.g.- magic bean) plus she seemed to gather herself rather quickly when Emma broke the curse. As mad as Dr. Whale got, he didn't seem to register immediately who EQ/Regina was or what had happened. But BF was all over it.

however she DID tell Geppetto she didn't like lying...

she lied to the war council when she said the wardrobe could only hold one.

She lied to Rumple when she said there wasn't any other ways to Our World after Bae had used the Magic Bean. Can't remember if there have been any other blatant lies.

okay that clears a lot up. instead of think she's evil i meant to say when did she lie? i didnt think she lied about the portal - she just asked gepetto not to sent pinocchio through it with emma but he did anyway. i must have dozed off during an episode where it was blatant that she lied about other ways to the real world.

rra615 wrote:how do we know that mr. gold wasn't able to remember anything until hearing emma's name? at the end of 1x02, he said "please" in asking regina for something which was a clause in the curse. i think he always knew and was spinning it the whole time.

why do some people think the BF is evil? what evidence do we have of that and what evidence is there that she knew of the curse as well as jefferson?

The writers confirmed somewhere...facebook pod cast maybe?...don't remember now...but they DID confirm that

Spoiler:

This also falls in line with why he would want to know her name. He knew he would remember once she showed up.

Spoiler:

As for why some people think she is evil - I think that depends on the individual who thinks that. Personally I don't...I think she is kind of 'out of the best for all or the world' not necessarily out for what is best for an individual...some people could see that as being evil. Also the way she prevented Grumpy and Nova from being together and the way she was with the magic bean and her lying about other ways to our world leads some people to think she is evil.

As for what evidence that she always remembered - none really - that is total speculation. But consider a few things:

Somehow Pinocchio knew how to get to Storybrooke, He appeared familiar to Regina, someone set up August with a workshop, August went to her for council before the curse was broken, August NEVER confirms or denies if he had been to Storybrooke before, she was ALWAYS careful around Mr.Gold, she was making final preparations as the Blue Fairy, she knows so much about magic and The Curse and what would happen if it was enacted. She in a sense has had just as much time to prepare for this Dark Curse as Rumple did to create it.

Spoiler:

SO MUCH screams that there HAS to be someone other than Regina and Jefferson who remembered the curse ALL along and who also knew the prediction of the savior and a lot more about The Curse than Jefferson would have. Only person who I can think of that we have seen who would have had the possible power and know how is the Blue Fairy. Too much falls apart and leaves very pertinent questions if she didn't always remember. That is why I think she did remember...

how do we know that mr. gold wasn't able to remember anything until hearing emma's name? at the end of 1x02, he said "please" in asking regina for something which was a clause in the curse. i think he always knew and was spinning it the whole time.

why do some people think the BF is evil? what evidence do we have of that and what evidence is there that she knew of the curse as well as jefferson?

We KNOW that Mr. Gold didn't remember anything until he heard Emma's name...but SOMEHOW he was able to acquire Henry...Someone had to know what was up!

I am 99.9% confident that the Blue Fairy always remembered!

There is SOOO much that really doesn't add up with out someone else (other than Jefferson) who doesn't remember and knew a lot about the intimate details of the curse.

I think she remembered and she helped Mr. Gold get Henry. I think she also had communication with Pinocchio eventually over the years...

DAMN she better remember or there goes 90% of my theories on things!